5 Best BBQ Gloves — 2018 Review & Buyers Guide

selecting the best bbq glove for your kitchen

Everything you need to know about purchasing a trusted kitchen glove for your oven to your BBQ. It starts with understanding which type of material suits your cooking style. We have hand picked (no pun intended) our #1 glove for each type of cooking glove. 

Every MeatGeek knows that barbecue gloves are an important part of their cooking arsenal. 

Whether you’re adjusting logs in the flame and stirring the coals, moving hot grates and pans, or even picking the brisket right off the flames with your hands, a trusty set of gloves is a game-changer for adding ease and convenience to your BBQ game.

Like most other smoking accessories, BBQ gloves come in almost any shape, material or size – long sleeved, short cuffs, silicone, leather. You name it, you can probably find it. And you could spend as much or as little as your budget will allow.

Silicone glove

To help make sense of all these options, we’ve rounded up, tested, and selected the best BBQ gloves available to keep your hands guarded. Read on to see which one is best for you. Here's a quick look at the 5 winners, click the see now button to see the current price over at Amazon.com, or click the brand name for a quick scroll down to our review.

WHICH GLOVE IS BEST FOR THE WAY YOU COOK?

First things first, there are four types of barbecue gloves:

  1. Silicone
  2. Leather
  3. Fabric
  4. Synthetic

Each glove material has its own strengths and appropriate uses. For example, silicone is excellent for handling food directly, as it is non-stick and simple to clean, and totally food-safe. Leather gloves are great for handling hot logs, coals and grill parts. However, neither silicon nor leather does well when it comes to handling utensils such as knives,as they are just too bulky.

  • Silicone
  • Leather
  • Fabric
  • Synthetic

Synthetic gloves usually consist of a rubber or silicone exteriorlined with fabric, whether synthetic or natural fabric (like cotton). These gloves don’t insulate your hands as well as leather gloves, are nimbler and allow you to handle tongs and utensils easily.You can even handle food directly. They’ll feel similar to a pair of dish gloves, but much thicker and higher-quality. They’re also easy to clean thanks to the rubber exterior; just soap and wash like you’re washing your hands. Keep in mind that you also can’t use them when wet, as water causes them to conduct heat.


Things to Pay Attention To When Choosing Barbecue Gloves

  • Dexterity = ​You’re looking for a solid grip on your tongs, tools and grates, and thick, stiff gloves make that much harder. You want to be able to use a knife or pair of tongs with ease, and grab logs and move coals around with one hand. Dexterity often comes at the sacrifice of thickness and heat-resistance, but if you’re a very hands-on smoker, might be worth the trade-off.

  • Cuff Length = ​Barbecue gloves come in different lengths, from wrist length to gauntlets that run all the way up to your elbow. The longer the cuff, the more it protects your arm over hot, flaming coals, when reaching over a large grill, and when grease starts to splash around. Cuff length can be a matter of personal preference, but if you have a large grill or smoker or like to cook over open flame, longer sleeves are worth it.

  • Heat-Resistance and Thickness = 
  • If your gloves aren’t rated to withstand high heat, they won’t do much good. They could melt, you could burn your hands, and all manner of bad things could go wrong from there. Temperatures in smokers and grills easily get up to 500-600 degrees, so don’t skimp on this one.

Best Silicone gloves (1 of 2)


1. Ekogrips BBQ Oven Gloves – MeatGeek Pick

ekogrips grill gloves

IMPORTANT DETAILS

The Ekogrips BBQ Oven Gloves are a quality, affordable pair of silicone gloves that you’ll find useful for more than just meat-geeking.

  • Come in three sizes: One Size Fits Most, L/XL and XXl
  • Have longer sleeves that come up past your wrist to your mid-forearm; this makes them useful not just for reaching into a hot grill, but also for dealing with boiling water and ovens
  • Silicone build is 100% waterproof, unlike fabric or leather gloves, which keeps steam and hot juices out.
  • Build quality is excellent, and gloves even feature reinforced seams between the fingers for more durability

FOOD HANDLING

As they are made of silicone, the Ekogripsare an excellent for handling food directly. They are both non-slip and non-stick – a unique strength of this glove- and you can count on an easy cleanup. No matter what crud, grease, or grime gets on them, just toss in the dishwasher.

They’re comfortably thick and insulated, rated to withstand temperatures up to 425 degrees, and the silicone is BPA-free and FDA food grade.

DRAWBACKS

Unfortunately, the Ekogrips aren’t very comfortable. They’re thick and floppy, and are designed for picking up large roasts and moving hot items, as opposed to using knives and slicing meat. Even using tongs over the grill can be difficult. And like most gloves, they aren’t meant for holding hot items for more than a few seconds before heat comes through. Ekogrips even warns not to grip items too tightly, as this will cause heat to transfer through the glove faster.

They also tend stick to your hands; even the inside is quite grippy and will actually grip your skin, making them difficult to get on and off, and the thickness and lack of breathability means your hands sweat easily, adding to the problem.

Pros

  • Food-grade silicon, good for handling food directly
  • Extreme grip 
  • Super easy to clean; stain-resistant
  • Dishwasher safe
  • 100% waterproof
  • BPA-free, food-grade

Cons

  • Hard to get on and off
  • Doesn't protect from heat for long
  • Not breathable (hands get sweaty quickly)
  • times-circle
    Limited dexterity
  • times-circle
    Oversized fingers

OVERALL

The Ekogrips BBQ Oven Gloves are durable, versatile silicone gloves that provide excellent grip when handling roasts and briskets directly, opening and closing and moving hot grill parts, and are stain-resistant and super easy to clean.


SILICONE GLOVES (2 OF 2)


2. Man Law BBQ Gloves – MeatGeek Pick

grabbing chicken oven

IMPORTANT DETAILS

Man Law BBQ gloves are the perfect combination of heat-resistant and heavy-duty.

  • ​Heat-resistant up to 572 degrees (not as heat resistant as the Grill Armor gloves but more so than the Ekogrips)

  • Good for reaching into the grill, moving your brisket around, grabbing hot pans for up to a minute before heat leaks through.

They have a food-grade silicone exterior with thick deep ridges that provide extra grip on hot items and are seriously tough; simply putting them on your hands is an instant confidence booster.

The cuffs extend a total of 13” down your forearm, adding extra security when you’d like to reach into the smoker. They are also lined with cotton on the inside, which prevents them from sticking to your hands and comfort against the hot rubber.

And despite the thickness, these gloves remain quite dexterous and nimble, and you can use your tongs, forks and knives with ease. Great for such a protective glove.

Pros

  • Food-grade silicone, great for handling food directly
  • Extreme grip
  • Heat-resistant up to 572º F
  • Long cuffs for additional protection
  • Very comfortable

Cons

  • Not as durable as the build quality seems

OVERALL

These are another awesome pair of silicone BBQ glove; they keep your hands cool when handling very hot metal and hot meat directly. They’re comfortable, nimble enough for utensils, and easy to clean. What’s not to like?

Best Fabric Glove


3. Grill Armor 932 – MeatGeek Pick

fabric gloves

IMPORTANT DETAILS

Our pick for best fabric gloves are the Grill Armor 932F, which, like the Pit Mitt, are constructed using aramid fibers.

  • Rated to withstand a whopping 932º F (far hotter than any smoker or grill should ever get)

  • Heat resistant enough to make you feel invincible in the face of a raging inferno (though we still don’t recommend sticking your hand directly into the fire)

  • Only comes in two sizes: one size fits most (regular), and ladies (small)

  • Comes in four different colors (blue, black, red, grey)

HEAT RESISTANCE

While we haven’t tested these gloves at 500ºF plus, you won’t have any problems grabbing hot meat, moving grates and logs around, or even picking up hot pans and carrying them to the table. They are only designed to stand up to intense levels of heat for about 25-30 seconds.

FIT

They’re thick, but not too thick, with a cool cotton lining inside that keeps them flexible and useable and lets you use utensils easily. The silicone texture on the palms and fingers add extra grip for a firm handle on your food.

DRAWBACKS

One thing we don’t like about the Grill Armor gloves is they only have two sizes (regular and small). This makes them too loose and bulky on smaller hands, and hard to get on and off larger hands.

And, like other fabric gloves, you can’t use these when wet. Luckily, they air-dry well and are machine-washable.

Pros

  • Rated to 932F (Overkill for any grilling)
  • Cool, cotton lining keeps your hands comfortable
  • Prevents sweating
  • Thin, flexible enough to use tools
  • Thick enough to protect hands
  • check-circle
    Silicon texturing adds grip

Cons

  • Only two sizes – Regular and Small
  • times-circle
    Odd sizing for many hands
  • times-circle
    Lose insulation when wet
  • times-circle
    Not for use around liquids

OVERALL

There isn’t much not to like about the Grill Armor. They are supremely comfortable, dexterous, and practically bulletproof at protecting your hands from intense, high heat. Grill Armor gloves are our pick for the best fabric gloves, and they come in 4 different colors, so you can find a pair you like.

Best LEATHER Glove


4. Steven RaichleN eXTRA lONG – MeatGeek Pick

best leather food gloves

IMPORTANT DETAILS

These extra-long suede gloves from Steven Raichlen are our pick for the best leather barbecue gloves.

  • Feature 18-inch long gauntlets that run up to your elbow, providing total protection from hot coals and flames and splashing grease

  • Interior is lined with cotton for comfort

HEAT RESISTANCE

These gloves are not intended for prolonged exposure to high heat. They are supposedly rated to about 475 degrees, but they won’t insulate your hands from extremely hot items and grates, as they are not actually insulated. You can feel the heat go right through them. They work better for things like lighting coals, using tongs, poking around inside the smoker, but not grabbing hot metal.

FIT

Where these gloves shine is in just how comfortable and nimble they are, especially for a pair of leather gloves. They’re pliable, and you can easily handle utensils, tongs and even knives without much trouble – something that can’t be said for all leather gloves.

DRAWBACKS

They are also not machine-washable, which means oil and grit gets easily stuck in the fabric.

Pros

  • Look cool. Really cool.
  • Dexterous, pliable and comfortable
  • Works well with knives/utensils
  • Long gauntlets for protection
  • Large arms keep arms cool

Cons

  • Not much insulation against heat
  • times-circle
    Not machine-washable

OVERALL

These are solid leather gloves for cooking over the grill and doing basic tasks. They provide ample protection up and down your arms, while stilling letting you handle tongs or knives with ease. And the large, roomy arms allow airflow to keep you cool.

Best Synthetic gloves


5. mitt pitt – MeatGeek Pick

best synthetic glove

IMPORTANT DETAILS

These gloves are very popular in the barbecue world, and for good reason. They’re made from aramid fiber, commonly used by the military and aviation industry thanks to its ultra-durability and heat-resistant properties.

  • Rated to withstand temperatures up to 475 degrees comfortably

  • Dose excellent job at blocking heat and keeping it from seeping through the fabric.

  • Lets you pull hot pans out of the oven and move hot grill grates and logs, often for as long as 20-25 seconds.

HEAT RESISTANCE

The aramid fiber means these gloves are resistant to high heat of up to 475 degrees. Impressive for such a thin glove. You’ll be able to move pans, grill grates, logs with ease.

Remember, however, that despite the name – these are not oven mitts. They aren’t meant for carrying a large hot pan from the pit to the kitchen.

FIT

The Pit Mitt is also especially dexterous; the palm features silicone texturing to add grip, and the fit is very comfortable, thin and pliable. Using tongs and utensils is very doable and feels almost like not having gloves at all.

The cuffs are not full-length gauntlets, as you might find on the Steve Raichlen leather gloves, for example. But they come down over your wrists and onto your forearms, giving extra protection and comfort should you need to reach into the fire or deal with splashing grease.

DRAWBACKS

Unfortunately, the Pit Mitt is not waterproof or water-resistant in any way. And when the gloves do get wet, they lose much of their insulating ability, which makes handling hot metal dangerous.They’re also not machine-washable, and are one-size fits all, so if you have especially large or small hands like some of us, it might be hard to find the right fit.

Pros

  • excellent heat-resistance for their weight
  • aramid fibers insulate well
  • very dexterous
  • comfortable and easy-to-use
  • handle knives/utensils with ease
  • check-circle
    silicone texturing adds grip
  • check-circle
    extended cuff adds protection

Cons

  • not waterproof
  • times-circle
    not water-resistant
  • times-circle
    not machine-washable
5 Best BBQ Gloves — 2018 Review & Buyers Guide
4.5 (90%) 12 votes

Leave a Reply